How to Beat Slivers

Cyber-Spud · Posts: 35 Join date: 2008-09-18 Age: 15

No, im saying if you had the card and I have a card that automaticaly plays any card from any hand, i could make it so that it would summon that very card, therefore making you loose the game.

Charlotte · Subject: Re: How to Beat Slivers Sun Oct 12, 2008 9:39 pm

Cyber-Spud wrote:

No, im saying if you had the card and I have a card that automaticaly plays any card from any hand, i could make it so that it would summon that very card, therefore making you loose the game.

that being so, if its in my hand and you summon it, its still being played from my hand, so no i wouldnt.

_________________
-- Charlotte--
"an army has filled the valley, but its not like any army i have ever seen. there are no tents, no fires, no horses.. just a sea of bodies, writhing and moaning, as if a pestilant village were sent to invade us."

LilDragon · Subject: Re: How to Beat Slivers Mon Oct 13, 2008 1:58 pm

Im confused?!?!?! Suspect

_________________
The Brave May Die But The Weak May Never Live At All

Charlotte · Subject: Re: How to Beat Slivers Mon Oct 13, 2008 6:34 pm

that was my deivious plan..

no not really.. what cy is trying to tell me is that if he has a card that can summon one of my cards from my hand and he summons phage, i loose the game because it wasnt summoned from my hand.

but i am argueing that that is incorrect because for him to sumon phage is has to come from my hand.. so even though he is summoning it, it is still being played from my hand.

jaw drop

wow your right, that does sound complicated even in laymans terms... but do you get it now??

_________________
-- Charlotte--
"an army has filled the valley, but its not like any army i have ever seen. there are no tents, no fires, no horses.. just a sea of bodies, writhing and moaning, as if a pestilant village were sent to invade us."

LilDragon · Subject: Re: How to Beat Slivers Mon Oct 13, 2008 8:39 pm

Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

i get it now

and looking over all the evidence it is quite clear that kely is right because it strictly states FROME HIS?HER HAND and if someone where to summon phage from an opponent it would have to be within the opponents hand unless the card in question states from oponents deck but why would they make such a card lol

_________________
The Brave May Die But The Weak May Never Live At All

The Jasenator · Posts: 37 Join date: 2008-09-17 Age: 18

You are all making it sound SO much more complicated than what it is:

1. When Phage the Untouchable comes into play, if you DIDN'T play it from your hand you lose the game.

So CS is right if he forced it into play from your hand without you actually playing it, you would lose the game.
Thankfully this is impossible so we can safely ignore this.

However if it was discarded/destroyed and he forced Phage into play under your control from the graveyard you would also lose the game.

And if he forced it into play under his control from your graveyard he would lose the game, as activated and static abilities apply to the controller.

i.e YOU = CONTROLLER.

I hope this has cleared it all up.

_________________
"Some have said there is no subtley to destruction. You know what? They're all dead." - Jaya Ballard, Task Mage.

Cyber-Spud · Posts: 35 Join date: 2008-09-18 Age: 15

Wow..............
WIll you always do this when I ask a question? I could say something that has no possible solution and watch you try and solve it Laughing

But that clears things up.........Too bad I cant use that card against her.......

The Jasenator · Posts: 37 Join date: 2008-09-17 Age: 18

Cyber-Spud wrote:

Wow..............
WIll you always do this when I ask a question? I could say something that has no possible solution and watch you try and solve it Laughing

But that clears things up.........Too bad I cant use that card against her.......

Well I don't think a question can exist without a solution.

Unless it is a statement POSING as a question.

Then the question would become "What is the satement hidden in this question an why is is it crossdressing like a question"?

Which in itself is a question thereby creating MORE (MOAR) questions making your question obsolete in comparison with the other questions.

Or it could be some kind of mutant hybrid QUESTIONSATEMENT. Which I believe only the spanish have the power to create (According to the sentence I placed in wikipedia, and since it's on wikipedia it must be right)

Which would then prove you to be in someway part spanish, whether that is from decent or aliens abducted you and replaced your blood with that of a spanish man is another question (or statement) entirely.

I hope that this helped.

EDIT**

You could use the card against her as long as you had a way of bringing it from another location other than her hand into play under Phages owners control

_________________
"Some have said there is no subtley to destruction. You know what? They're all dead." - Jaya Ballard, Task Mage.

Cyber-Spud · Posts: 35 Join date: 2008-09-18 Age: 15

My head just exploded.
But it wasn't from your logic Jason, it was from a Spanish super alien virus that makes peoples head explode and never resolve anything they say........or do they?

Charlotte · Subject: Re: How to Beat Slivers Wed Oct 15, 2008 6:05 pm

ok update time.. i need to have my deck finished in the next three weeks..

these are the new cards i either have comming or am still contemplating buying..

is comming

the rest are being contemplated

_________________
-- Charlotte--
"an army has filled the valley, but its not like any army i have ever seen. there are no tents, no fires, no horses.. just a sea of bodies, writhing and moaning, as if a pestilant village were sent to invade us."

LilDragon · Subject: Re: How to Beat Slivers Wed Oct 15, 2008 8:51 pm

what about Dark ritual thats a good card to have remember

Title: Dark Ritual
Cost:B
Type: Instant
Raraty: common
Text:
Add BBB to your mana pool

"Eye of twilight, give us sight.
Take our offer, give us might.
Make our power tears of night"

Illustrations: Rebecca Guay

_________________
The Brave May Die But The Weak May Never Live At All

Cyber-Spud · Posts: 35 Join date: 2008-09-18 Age: 15

That one that lildrgon just said would be very handy for early game, you could slap the opponent in the face before they even had time to wake up to what happened

LilDragon · Subject: Re: How to Beat Slivers Wed Oct 15, 2008 9:29 pm

Exactly cos i have those in my world deck thats why its annoying cos i might just have that and a plague spitter witch is worth 2B soo bam i already have a creature out in the first upkeep Twisted Evil

_________________
The Brave May Die But The Weak May Never Live At All

The Jasenator · Posts: 37 Join date: 2008-09-17 Age: 18

LilDragon wrote:

what about Dark ritual thats a good card to have remember

Title: Dark Ritual
Cost:B
Type: Instant
Raraty: common
Text:
Add BBB to your mana pool

"Eye of twilight, give us sight.
Take our offer, give us might.
Make our power tears of night"

Illustrations: Rebecca Guay

People in Vintage tournaments play Dark Rituals then slap out phage on turn one.
They are also useful for turn one wins.
It is the best mana acceleration card ever.

_________________
"Some have said there is no subtley to destruction. You know what? They're all dead." - Jaya Ballard, Task Mage.

Charlotte · Subject: Re: How to Beat Slivers Thu Oct 16, 2008 2:57 pm

ok ok guys i get the hint..
i need dark rituals lol..
i will look for them right now..

hehe this deck will

_________________
-- Charlotte--
"an army has filled the valley, but its not like any army i have ever seen. there are no tents, no fires, no horses.. just a sea of bodies, writhing and moaning, as if a pestilant village were sent to invade us."